Looks like we have a small bug here. If you select: Hide on selected & Logged in users the widget is not being hidden. We will fix that shortly. I did the desired effect by selecting: Display on selected & Logged out users – it is being hidden. This happens only if you don’t apply any more conditions (like Front Page, Blog etc.)
So generally, I have set it the way you like it to (this widget is not being displayed for logged in users) – use this combination please, before we make a fix and update the plugin.
How to Get Support
After you register and login to the site, you may post all plugin support questions in the Support Forum.
If you need to provide private info, please create a ticket and then reply to it using Set as private reply option.