Matt, try a two things:
1. resave plugin both settings: general and for specific lightbox script (prettyphoto)
2. if it does not help, deacitvate and delete a plugin, install it again and setup your options
After you register and login to the site, you may post all plugin support questions in the Support Forum.
If you need to provide private info, please create a ticket and then reply to it using Set as private reply option.